86

Mystery of the Abbey is an atmospheric deduction board game heavily inspired by Clue, set within a medieval monastery. Players move around the abbey interviewing monks, gathering clues, and ruling out attributes to uncover which monk committed the murder.

Where to buy

Buying through these links supports BGV at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

86

The Verdict

based on 8 reviews

Positive 0%
Better, dice-free alternative to Clue
Creative, open-ended questioning
Points for revelations, not just naming culprit
Good components and easy rules
Some randomness and dated mechanics
Silence strategy can be overused
Limited movement; left neighbor shapes what you see
Icon-only sheets and small shield
95
StatedThis reviewer gave their own score. We only converted it to our 0–100 scale.
TheBoardGameFamily, TheBoardGameFamilyVideo

“What would you rate Mystery of the Abbey? 4.75. Wow, I'm very high mark in your book, huh? That's your pen again. Awesome, big thumbs up then.”(8:26)

90
InferredThis reviewer didn't give a numbered score. We read the review and inferred a 0–100 score from what they said. Did we get it wrong? Please report it, we'll fix it.
The Board Game Family, TrentArticle

“So if you like family deduction board games, we'd highly recommend you pick up a copy of Mystery of the Abbey!”

90
InferredThis reviewer didn't give a numbered score. We read the review and inferred a 0–100 score from what they said. Did we get it wrong? Please report it, we'll fix it.
The Dice Tower, The Dice TowerVideo

“Overall, awesome game, awesome components, uh, there's a reason why it's been out for a long time but yet it keeps getting reprinted and you see it being played everywhere. It is a good game to replace Clue.”(12:53)

90
InferredThis reviewer didn't give a numbered score. We read the review and inferred a 0–100 score from what they said. Did we get it wrong? Please report it, we'll fix it.
The Boardgame Mechanics, The Boardgame MechanicsArticleTop List – #91

“If you can get your hands on this game and you like Clue and stuff, it's so fun. So my number 91 is Mystery of the Abbey. It is definitely a good one. Um, I would rather play this over Clue any day of the week. It's good.”

See list
85
StatedThis reviewer gave their own score. We only converted it to our 0–100 scale.
Board Game Reviews by Josh, JoshArticle

“Overall, I give Mystery of the Abbey an 8.5/10. I looked forward to trying it out for quite some time, and I wasn't disappointed. If you like whodunit games, this is one that I think you can play with your entire family.”

85
InferredThis reviewer didn't give a numbered score. We read the review and inferred a 0–100 score from what they said. Did we get it wrong? Please report it, we'll fix it.
boardgamecloset, boardgameclosetVideo

“I think you ought to buy this game. If you like Clue, I think it's great, right? Um the the game the game just plays fun.”(15:33)

80
InferredThis reviewer didn't give a numbered score. We read the review and inferred a 0–100 score from what they said. Did we get it wrong? Please report it, we'll fix it.
GeekDad, Dave BanksArticle

“We really enjoyed Mystery of the Abbey and it represents a fresh take of the deduction game. As someone who missed out on previous printings, I am glad we got the opportunity to play this game because it is a great family game with lots of interaction”

75
InferredThis reviewer didn't give a numbered score. We read the review and inferred a 0–100 score from what they said. Did we get it wrong? Please report it, we'll fix it.
Game Boy Geek, Game Boy GeekVideo

“If you're looking for a family weight deduction game that you don't mind some ziness, some craziness, and some randomness in there, but you want some interesting deduction with some creative question asking, Mystery Abby still fits that bill.”(10:16)

Lists to explore

View all top lists

Stay in the loop

Fresh reviews, hyped games and top lists — straight to your inbox, once a week.

Board Game Verdict

© 2026 Board Game Verdict

AboutMethodologyEthicsFAQContact usPrivacy policy·····