Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases (1981)

Now subtitled “The Thames Murders & Other Mysteries”, it remains the best deduction game I’ve ever played and, despite some minor flaws, a truly engrossing experience.

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective transcends the typical board game experience, offering a mental challenge that transports players to the heart of Victorian London.

The reviewer highly recommends Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective, praising its ability to make players feel genuinely challenged and even a bit foolish, which paradoxically enhances the experience of grappling with complex mysteries.

The reviewer highly recommends "Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases," praising it as one of the best choices for the Spiel des Jahres award and the very best deduction game for storytelling, highlighting its timeless appeal and immersive narrative.

The reviewer enthusiastically praises 'Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective' as an amazing and immersive experience, highlighting its strong theme, brilliant newspaper design, and fantastic writing, noting it's the only game that truly made them feel like a detective and placing it near the top of their cooperative board games list.

The reviewer expresses strong affection for the game, highlighting their love for solving mysteries and the rich, thematic Victorian London setting. They particularly enjoy the cooperative storytelling aspect, finding it a unique and engaging experience.

Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective is an outstanding exercise in self-flagellation, executed with grace and poise. We can all do with being humbled on occasion. Pick it up, you’ll be a wiser person for it.

The reviewer's opinion, based on general sentiment surrounding the game, is highly positive, praising it as an excellent and immersive deduction experience that effectively captures the spirit of Sherlock Holmes.

The reviewer highlights 'Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective' as a rich, narrative-driven, cooperative storytelling experience that effectively immerses players in solving challenging mysteries and attempting to outwit Sherlock Holmes himself.

The reviewer praises "Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases" as an excellent deduction game, offering an immersive experience that surpasses similar titles and provides a genuinely challenging and rewarding mystery to solve.

Rahdo finds the game to be a lovely and fun investigative experience that truly makes players feel like detectives, despite some issues with typos in a few cases and a scoring mechanism that can detract from the rich narrative.

The video provides a highly positive overview of 'Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases,' highlighting its immersive ability to challenge players' deductive reasoning and capture the mystery of Victorian London through thoroughly researched cases and engaging mechanics.