BoardGame Verdict
89

A large-scale strategy board game of skill and intrigue set in an ancient, crumbling kingdom where players are heirs vying for control of a vacant throne. The game features card-driven conquest mechanics with heavy emphasis on bluffing, blind bidding, and tactical maneuvering as players attempt to claim locations and outmaneuver their opponents.

Where to Buy

If BGV helped you pick your next game, buying through our links helps our small team keep the site running.

AD320×100
89

The Verdict

based on 22 reviews

Positive 0%
Mixed 0%
Negative 0%
Exceptional and breathtaking artwork and production quality.
Deep, strategic, and engaging gameplay with a high degree of replayability.
Well-designed asymmetric factions that provide varied and interesting gameplay.
An innovative and successful blend of various game mechanics, including area control, bluffing, and deck building.
Creates a tense and captivating experience with meaningful player interaction.
The game has a high complexity level, making it difficult and time-consuming to teach and learn.
Gameplay can feel chaotic and overwhelming, particularly with more players, which may feel random to some.
Requires a significant amount of table space to play.
The experience can be polarizing, appealing more to dedicated players who can invest time in repeated plays.
100
Wargamer, Alex EvansArticle

“It's simply the most surprising, joyous, visually spectacular, strategically sparkling, thematically fulsome board game I've played in recent memory. I believe it's one of the best board games ever made.”

Read article
95
Space-Biff!, Dan ThurotArticle

“It’s the masterful blend of art and gameplay that evokes a wider world, one halfway submerged between legend and reality. That this is Pablo Clark’s freshman project is frankly astonishing.”

Read article
95
Shut Up & Sit Down, TomVideo

The reviewer from Shut Up & Sit Down expressed exceptionally high praise for 'The Old King's Crown,' considering it a potentially phenomenal and beautiful game that could be one of the best releases of its year.

Watch video
95
Dicebreaker, MattArticle

“The Old King’s Crown sharpens up a delightfully cut-throat competition of competing factions and ruthless cardplay that has quickly made it my most anticipated release of next year.”

Read article
95
No Pun Included, Efka BladukasVideo

The Old King's Crown features clever mechanics and fresh design choices, creating an engaging and tense experience driven by risk and reward, which makes it arguably one of the most exciting games of the year.

Watch video
95
Board Game Hangover, Board Game HangoverArticleTop List

The reviewer highly praises "The Old King's Crown" as a visually stunning game with engaging tactical card play and hidden information, although they note potential downtime with four players. They consider it one of the best games played that month.

See list
95
One Stop Coop Shop, Mike KellyVideo

The reviewer highly praised 'The Old King's Crown,' calling it one of his recent favorites, particularly highlighting the solo mode as being exceptionally well-designed for this competitive area domination and card-based combat game.

Watch video
90
Meeple Mountain, Andrew LynchArticle

“Beneath all the hype, The Old King’s Crown is indeed a very good game. It is full of lies and tricks, feints and triumphs.”

Read article
90
Punchboard, AdamArticle

“The Old King’s Crown is just wonderful. It’s the kind of game that you’d imagine would lead to some ‘kill the king’ when someone races ahead, and to some extent that’s true, but for every ally with a hand on your shoulder, you’d better believe they’re holding a stiletto tip at your ribs too.”

Read article
90
Totally Tabled, Totally TabledVideo

The reviewer highly recommends 'The Old King's Crown' for its solo mode, praising its stunning artwork and innovative design within the lane battler genre, though noting it might not appeal to everyone due to its specific style.

Watch video
90
Rahdo Runs Through, RahdoVideo

Rahdo explores why The Old King's Crown is highly ranked on BoardGameGeek's hotness list, indicating its strong appeal and widespread positive reception within the board gaming community.

Watch video
90
IGN, Matt ThrowerArticle

“The Old King’s Crown is a grab bag of concepts from all sorts of other board games, each given a loving polish and shape to fit it into a greater whole, wrapped in the most amazing eye candy, creating a unique package.”

Read article
90
Liege of Games, ChrisVideo

The reviewer highly recommends "The Old King's Crown," praising its unique Kingdom cards, strategic depth, and engaging player interaction, though noting a potential learning curve for the first few plays. They consider it one of the best overall games.

Watch video
90
Not Bored Gaming, MarkArticleTop List

The reviewer enthusiastically praises "The Old King's Crown" as an absolutely fantastic game, particularly highlighting its wonderfully realized solo mode and stunning artwork, which successfully implements intriguing blind bidding mechanics and asymmetrical factions.

See list
90
Player EliminationArticle

“In all facets, The Old King’s Crown embraces excitement. While some may rebuke this creation, others will embrace it with infatuation. I’m far more in that latter camp.”

Read article
90
The Cardboard Herald, JackVideo

The reviewer highly praises "The Old King's Crown" as one of the most fascinating and unconventional board game debuts in a long time, noting its refined and sophisticated gameplay that becomes very tight with familiarity. However, they acknowledge it is not for everyone due to its busy nature, lack of immediate intuitiveness, and potentially punishing consequences for bad moves.

Watch video
90
Cardboard Minute, Cardboard MinuteVideo

The reviewer highly praises "The Old King's Crown" for its exceptional beauty, stellar production quality, and stunning artwork, noting that the game appears complex due to its substantial rulebook.

Watch video
85
The Dice Tower, Tom Vasel, Zee Garcia, and ChrisVideo

The Old King's Crown is praised for its stunning visuals, mechanical ambition, and deep strategic gameplay that offers a unique experience for players who enjoy psychological warfare and are willing to delve into its complexity. While one reviewer found it convoluted and chaotic, another highlighted its 'Cosmic Encounter' feel and surprising enjoyability for those who invest time in mastering it.

Watch video
80
Bower's Game Corner, BowerVideo

The reviewer found 'The Old King's Crown' to be a fun game with appealing artwork once he delved past the initial presentation, despite some issues with the Kickstarter campaign's organization and a lack of immediate engagement in its initial minutes.

Watch video
70
Frank N Dice, Frank N DiceVideo

The reviewer found "The Old King's Crown" to offer engaging tactical decisions, betting, and bluffing, but highlighted that its full appreciation requires a dedicated gaming group due to the rules complexity being slightly above the gameplay and the potential for long play sessions.

Watch video
60
The Broken Meeple, Luke HectorVideo

The reviewer praises the game's gorgeous artwork and intriguing card system, but notes its complexity and highly interactive, confrontational nature might make it divisive and potentially leave some players feeling disengaged in multiplayer sessions.

Watch video
45
Board Game Critique, Board Game CritiqueVideo

The reviewer cautions against buying The Old King's Crown, noting that despite its enormous depth and layered decisions, its excessive complexity often feels like administrative overhead. They emphasize that the overwhelming hidden information can lead to a perception of randomness, making it a game best suited for dedicated and consistent play groups rather than casual or rotating game nights.

Watch video
AD320×100
AD320×100

Stay in the loop

Fresh reviews, hyped games and top lists — straight to your inbox, once a week.

BoardGame Verdict

© 2026 BoardGame Verdict

AboutMethodologyEthicsFAQContact UsPrivacy Policy·····
AD320×50