85

Set in 15th-century Portugal, players develop the island of Madeira, manage cities, and improve the economy while balancing the demands of the Portuguese crown, population, and pirates. It is known as a complex and challenging heavy Euro game requiring deep tactical awareness and strategic planning.

85

The Verdict

based on 8 reviews

Positive 0%
Clever, unique dice-placement system
Deep, rewarding, interlocking Euro mechanisms
Agonizing choices and high replay value
Excellent components and graphics
Steep learning curve and overwhelming heaviness
Harsh pirate-token penalty
Confusing terminology and rulebook issues
Theme feels loose
90
InferredThis reviewer didn't give a numbered score. We read the review and inferred a 0–100 score from what they said. Did we get it wrong? Please report it, we'll fix it.
Gaming Rules!, Gaming Rules!Video

“Madeira, as I mentioned, [is] one of my top 5 games of all time. Absolutely loved it, will never say no to playing it. If you do like your heavy crunchy euros, then getting it or playing a friend's copy is a no-brainer.”(10:41)

90
InferredThis reviewer didn't give a numbered score. We read the review and inferred a 0–100 score from what they said. Did we get it wrong? Please report it, we'll fix it.
UndeadVikingVideos, UndeadVikingVideosVideo

“It's just it's a fan fastic game if you are looking for a a analysis paralysis mind crushing Euro um I I I strongly suggest this isn't the heaviest game I've ever played uh as far as Euros go definitely not but it is it is right there”(57:23)

90
StatedThis reviewer gave their own score. We only converted it to our 0–100 scale.
The Boardgame Mechanics, The Boardgame MechanicsVideo

“This game is fantastic and I am so glad I finally have a copy and this is going to get a BGM accepted seal. This is going to get a full, um, for a 9 out of 10 on BGG, which is a 4.5 out of 5 wrenches.”(25:01)

90
InferredThis reviewer didn't give a numbered score. We read the review and inferred a 0–100 score from what they said. Did we get it wrong? Please report it, we'll fix it.
Totally Tabled, Totally TabledArticleTop List – #16

“Number 16 is Madeira. It's an absolute brain burner for me but I adore it. In fact, this is another one where you're rolling some dice and then using those dice to take actions, but”

See list
85
InferredThis reviewer didn't give a numbered score. We read the review and inferred a 0–100 score from what they said. Did we get it wrong? Please report it, we'll fix it.
Drive Thru Games, Drive Thru GamesVideo

“I think if you're a venos fan this would definitely be right up your alley I think this is definitely at least as strong as as venos in that regard graphically you know it's across the board excellent”(25:32)

85
InferredThis reviewer didn't give a numbered score. We read the review and inferred a 0–100 score from what they said. Did we get it wrong? Please report it, we'll fix it.
Rahdo Runs Through, Rahdo Runs ThroughVideo

“This game is so rich and so rewarding and so big um even though it seems to have such very simple humble Origins just a simple collection of stuff”(0:52)

80
InferredThis reviewer didn't give a numbered score. We read the review and inferred a 0–100 score from what they said. Did we get it wrong? Please report it, we'll fix it.
The Dice Tower, The Dice TowerVideo

“So, lots of strategy, but some also tactical choices to be made in here. Uh, great game that uses dice in a kind of unique way. Check it out.”(16:18)

80
StatedThis reviewer gave their own score. We only converted it to our 0–100 scale.
Topping the Table, Jamie HopkinsArticle

If you love strategy games that offer great depth and replayability, Madeira is a must-have in your collection.

Lists to explore

View all top lists

Stay in the loop

Fresh reviews, hyped games and top lists — straight to your inbox, once a week.

Board Game Verdict

© 2026 Board Game Verdict

AboutMethodologyEthicsFAQContact usPrivacy policy·····