Horrified: American Monsters (2021)
(2021)Horrified: American Monsters is a cooperative board game where players team up to defeat iconic American cryptids such as Bigfoot, Mothman, the Jersey Devil, and the Chupacabra. Released in 2021, it is a standalone sequel to the original Horrified game, featuring similar gameplay where investigators must work together to overcome unique monster challenges. The game supports 1 to 5 players and is recommended for ages 10 and up.
Where to buy
If BGV helped you pick your next game, buying through our links helps our small team keep the site running. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
The Verdict
based on 12 reviews
With American Monsters, Ravensburger took everything that was great about Horrified and tweaked it just enough to make it feel like it should—part of a franchise. If you want a good cooperative game that offers a lot of replay value, plus has some great artwork and a monster-based theme that isn’t too scary for slightly younger family members, then you can’t go wrong with either Horrified title.
This video provides an overview and review of Horrified: American Monsters, examining its mechanics, component quality, and how it compares to the original game.
The content features a community-voted tier list of fall and spooky board games. Horrified: American Monsters is placed into a tier based on its theme and personal enjoyment.
This video provides a complete overview, rules explanation, and review of Horrified: American Monsters, comparing it directly to the original game.
Horrified: American Monsters is an atmospheric and engaging cooperative game that successfully builds on the original's formula with unique cryptid mechanics, adjustable difficulty, and charming 1950s small-town aesthetics.
The reviewer examines the mechanics, components, and cooperative gameplay of Horrified: American Monsters, offering a clear evaluation of its strengths and weaknesses compared to the original game.
Mike DiLisio gives Horrified: American Monsters a strong review, praising its cooperative gameplay and horror theme.
Mike DiLisio reviews Horrified: American Monsters, detailing its cooperative gameplay, folklore-inspired monsters, and components while offering a final verdict.
Horrified: American Monsters is a solid, entry-level cooperative game that successfully adapts the streamlined mechanics of the original while introducing fresh, unique challenges and win conditions via its new cryptid characters.
Horrified: American Monsters is a great addition featuring fun quality-of-life upgrades, though it shares the same core loop as the original and isn't a mandatory purchase for existing owners.
The video focuses on solo play of the base Horrified game. It does not target or review the distinct "Horrified: American Monsters" edition.
As a co-op game, it’s fine. And that’s part of my problem with the game: it’s fine. I can accept what it is and how it works but, for me, it brings nothing new or exciting to the table.
Where to buy
If BGV helped you pick your next game, buying through our links helps our small team keep the site running. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Horrified series
Similar games
Similar theme
Lists to explore
View all lists & features
Top 25Top 25 Best Horror Board Games 2026
Monsters, madness and things that go bump in the night: the top-rated horror games.
Top 25Best Cooperative board games
Win together or lose together — co-op games worth rallying your table around.
RankedJamey Stegmaier board games, ranked
From Wingspan to Scythe — see how Jamey Stegmaier's games stack up.
Top 25Best 2 player-only board games
Find out which games to play with your loved ones, siblings, friends, kids or parents.










