BoardGame Verdict
86

A cooperative horror board game where investigators in the 1920s attempt to disrupt cult rituals and defeat Elder Gods from H.P. Lovecraft's mythos. Players work together to first weaken the summoned Elder One during its ritual phase, then battle it directly in an action-packed finale.

Where to Buy

If BGV helped you pick your next game, buying through our links helps our small team keep the site running.

AD320×100
86

The Verdict

based on 27 reviews

Positive 0%
Mixed 0%
Negative 0%
Engaging insanity system that provides strategic depth by balancing risk and reward for powerful abilities.
High replayability due to a modular design allowing players to combine different Elder Gods and scenarios.
Accessible and easy-to-learn rules, making it quick to set up and get to the table.
Fast-paced and exciting gameplay, delivering a thematic rollercoaster ride of action and monster-slaying.
Excellent cooperative player interaction that scales well across different player counts without rule adjustments.
Miniatures can be too large for the map tiles, leading to an overcrowded board and difficulties with token placement.
Significant dice and card randomness can lead to frustrating outcomes and sudden losses.
Lack of a campaign element, which was a disappointment for some given one of the designers' previous work on legacy games.
Damage tracking for monsters can be impractical due to limited space on the board and miniature bases.
100
Meeple Mountain, Joseph BuszekArticle

“Simply put, this game delivered some of the best times I’ve had playing with a group of friends in a very long time and I can’t wait to get back in the fight and go a little (or, better yet, a lot) insane.”

Read article
100
Dale the Casual Gamer, Alex RadcliffeVideo

The reviewer enthusiastically praises Cthulhu: Death May Die as one of his all-time favorite games, highlighting its fun dungeon-crawl experience and engaging mechanics despite some minor inconsistencies in player count and episode quality.

Watch video
100
Board Game Coffee, Board Game CoffeeVideo

The reviewer enthusiastically recommends "Cthulhu: Death May Die," calling it one of their all-time favorite games that consistently provides a thoroughly enjoyable experience and has remained a top 10 title for them due to its engaging gameplay and high replayability.

Watch video
100
Board Game TipsArticle

“Cthulhu: Death May Die offers a unique and thrilling experience for players who enjoy Lovecraftian horror and cooperative strategy games. Its blend of insanity, strategic summoning, and survival creates an intense and memorable gameplay experience.”

Read article
95
Fuzzy Llama Reviews, Fuzzy Llama ReviewsArticle

“I mean, I love it. I love it so much more than I thought I would and I’m so glad that Rob and Eric teamed up and brought this to us.”

Read article
95
BoardGameCo, Alex RadcliffeVideo

The reviewer considers Cthulhu: Death May Die one of his all-time favorite games, consistently placing it in his top 10 since he first played it, and highly recommends it for its engaging and fun gameplay.

Watch video
95
Tabletop Bellhop, GreyWizardGamingVideo

The reviewer highly praises Cthulhu: Death May Die, emphasizing its high-quality production, excellent miniatures, and immersive thematic experience that successfully blends Lovecraftian horror with satisfying, dice-driven combat where going mad is a core, enjoyable mechanic.

Watch video
90
The Dungeon Dive, The Dungeon DiveVideo

The reviewer highlights Cthulhu: Death May Die as an action-packed, 'Wild Bunch' style take on the Cthulhu Mythos, where players are powerful investigators actively fighting Elder Gods rather than succumbing to dread, embracing insanity for strength.

Watch video
90
Man vs Meeple, Not Bored GamingVideo

The reviewer highlights Cthulhu: Death May Die for its remarkable balance, consistently delivering tense and exciting gameplay while telling a unique and fun story through its various scenarios. They particularly enjoy it as a cooperative experience, finding it engaging even for solo play.

Watch video
90
SideGame LLCVideo

The reviewer considers "Cthulhu: Death May Die" to be an excellent and refreshingly action-packed horror dungeon crawl, offering a lighthearted, 'beer and pretzels' experience focused on direct combat rather than a deep narrative.

Watch video
90
Drive Thru Games, Drive Thru GamesVideo

The reviewer highly recommends Cthulhu: Death May Die, praising its engaging and escalating narrative, fun gameplay, and straightforward mechanics, particularly highlighting the enjoyable boss battles.

Watch video
90
Foster the Meeple, Jeff and Jamie (Foster the Meeple)Video

The reviewers highly recommend Cthulhu: Death May Die, praising its strong production, engaging theme, replayability, and dynamic dice-rolling combat, despite minor issues with some character playstyles and the desire for recessed player boards.

Watch video
90
Liege of Games, BoardGameCo (Alex) / Liege of GamesVideo

The reviewer considers Cthulhu: Death May Die to be a highly acclaimed and recommended game, consistently ranking it among their top favorites due to its well-loved gameplay.

Watch video
90
DicebreakerArticle

“The final result is as loopy as a cultist who’s stayed up all night reading the Necronomicon. And even to a confirmed Lovecraft-basher like me, it’s incredibly entertaining.”

Read article
90
Board Game GumboVideo

The reviewer expresses a strong liking for Cthulhu: Death May Die, appreciating its light-hearted, heavy combat approach and the varied scenarios and characters that offer engaging replayability and a fun push-your-luck mechanic with insanity.

Watch video
90
Co-op Board GamesArticleTop List

“Co-op Board Games praised Cthulhu: Death May Die for its engaging scenario variety, strategic insanity system, and tense gameplay. They highlighted its quick setup, ease of teaching, and significant replay value, recommending it especially for Cthulhu fans.”

See list
90
Purge Reviews, Purge ReviewsVideo

The reviewer highly recommends the "Black Goat of the Woods" expansion for "Cthulhu: Death May Die," noting that it provides excellent variety with new enemies and is a valuable addition for players who enjoy the base game.

Watch video
90
Board Game Hot Takes, Adam and Chris (Board Game Hot Takes)Video

The reviewers found Cthulhu: Death May Die to be a highly thematic and exciting game, offering a tense and epic experience with varied scenarios. They particularly praised its strong narrative and balanced gameplay, which consistently creates engaging moments.

Watch video
90
Rolling Solo, Adam SmithVideo

The reviewer highly praises Cthulhu: Death May Die as an excellent and refreshing 'popcorn' style horror dungeon crawl, appreciating its focus on immediate action, dice-rolling, and guaranteed boss battles over deep narrative complexity.

Watch video
90
The Dice TowerArticleTop List

“In Cthulhu: Death May Die, you and your fellow players represent investigators in the 1920s who instead of trying to stop the coming of Elder Gods, want to summon those otherworldly beings so that you can put a stop to them permanently.”

See list
85
One Stop Coop Shop, MikeVideo

The reviewer found Cthulhu: Death May Die to be a great and fun design, highlighting its unique scenario elements and addictive gameplay, despite some concerns regarding dice luck, Elder One predictability, and character balance.

Watch video
80
slickerdrips, slickerdripsVideo

The playthrough video showcases the intricate mechanics of Cthulhu: Death May Die, demonstrating player actions like managing stress and madness, battling cultists, and navigating scenarios to disrupt rituals. The reviewer's ongoing engagement with the gameplay suggests a positively interactive and absorbing experience with the game.

Watch video
80
The Discriminating Gamer, Cody CarlsonVideo

The reviewer presents 'Cthulhu: Death May Die' as an engaging cooperative Lovecraftian horror game from CMON, exploring whether its ghoulish theme delivers a thrilling game night experience through its mechanics and gameplay.

Watch video
75
Board Game Barrage, Orange TankArticle

“Before we outsource our work, we talk about Santa Monica, Steam Works, and Cthulhu: Death May Die.”

Read article
60
BoardGameBollocks, BoardGameBollocksVideo

The reviewer found Cthulhu: Death May Die to be a decent, cooperative adventure game that offers initial excitement with its exploration and varied investigators. However, they expressed concerns about its long-term replayability due to a quickly depleting content pool and a lack of narrative progression, ultimately deeming it an average experience after the initial novelty wears off.

Watch video
35
Tabletop Dungeon, Tabletop DungeonVideo

The reviewer found Cthulhu: Death May Die to be an immensely frustrating and infuriating experience, citing excessive randomness and unbalanced mechanics that often led to feelings of defeat rather than enjoyment.

Watch video
30
Bad At Boardgames, Bad At BoardgamesVideo

The reviewer found Cthulhu: Death May Die to be an intensely frustrating and overly random game, leading to a sense of wasted time rather than enjoyment due to its brutal difficulty and unpredictable elements.

Watch video
AD320×100
AD320×100

Stay in the loop

Fresh reviews, hyped games and top lists — straight to your inbox, once a week.

BoardGame Verdict

© 2026 BoardGame Verdict

AboutMethodologyEthicsFAQContact UsPrivacy Policy·····
AD320×50