BoardGame Verdict
88

Scythe is an engine-building board game set in an alternate-history 1920s period featuring farming, mechs, eurogame elements, and war. Players control factions vying for power in Eastern Europa, using asymmetric player powers to expand territory, upgrade actions, and build structures while managing resources and combat.

88

The Verdict

based on 49 reviews

Positive 0%
Mixed 0%
Stunning and evocative artwork and high-quality components, including detailed miniatures and dual-layered player boards.
A unique blend of game mechanics, including engine-building, area control, and resource management, with multiple paths to victory.
Asymmetric factions and variable player boards provide significant replayability and strategic variety.
The 'cold war' tension created by the constant threat of combat is a frequently praised and unique aspect of the gameplay.
A streamlined action selection system that makes turns quick and the game flow smoothly despite its strategic depth.
The game can be slow-paced, especially in the beginning, with limited player interaction.
The combat system is sometimes described as simplistic and anti-climactic.
Some critics feel there can be a disconnect between the wargame-like appearance (mechs) and the core engine-building eurogame mechanics, which might disappoint players expecting more direct conflict.
100
Meeple Mountain, JPArticleTop List

Scythe is a meaty and satisfying game that will appeal to gamers of all stripes. Every time I play this game, whether I win or lose, I am left excited and wanting to play again.

See list
100
Board Game Gumbo, B.J.ArticleTop List

Scythe has been the best experience of any game I have played in 2016 so far. Well designed, awesome production, tight finishes, and I love the reward system.

See list
100
Board Gamers AnonymousArticleTop List

Scythe may not be the best board game of all time, but it’s definitely the best of 2016. From its beautiful, evocative artwork, to a combination of euro and combat-based mechanics that will draw in players from both camps, this behemoth from Stonemaier Games will be around for a long time to come.

See list
96
Zatu GamesArticle

All in all, Scythe’s ability to drag me into its theme and core mechanisms has seen it become my favourite game I’ve ever played. I enjoy the engine building, intimidation before the war, and the sheer amount of choices available to players.

Read article
95
Nerds on EarthArticle

There are plenty of games where the theme and mechanics have a wonderfully symbiotic relationship, and I’d rank Scythe right up there near the top.

Read article
95
Gideon's Gaming, Gaming GideonArticle

Scythe is an incredibly well-designed game that will give you a great experience if you meet it where it stands. It’s earned my Golden Shield Award.

Read article
95
WhatBoardGameArticle

This is one of the best expansions I have ever played. It makes Scythe, a game I love, better in ways you cannot really imagine.

Read article
95
Ars Technica, Aaron ZimmermanArticle

But if you want a deep, puzzly, interactive—and overall, very fun—Euro-style board game that plays in about two hours, Scythe should absolutely be on your shelf. It’s early in the year as far as board game releases go, but Scythe is the best new game I’ve played in 2016.

Read article
95
Meeple and the MooseArticle

Scythe is a masterpiece in my opinion, and a game that I would happily play, any time, anywhere. It offers a unique blend of cold war tension and engine building bliss.

Read article
95
Punchboard, AdamArticle

If you’re looking for a medium-heavy Euro with a solid solo mode (by Automa Factory), oodles of replayability, and one that’s absolutely dripping with theme, you really can’t do any better than Scythe. It’s a modern masterpiece, and one that everyone should own and play.

Read article
95
GeekDadArticle

Go back Scythe right now. You won’t regret it. Scythe is a fantastic game and I was really bummed out when I had to pack it up and send it on to the next reviewer.

Read article
95
Inverse, Ben GuarinoArticle

I want to play Scythe until I’ve worn out all its moving parts, but it might just be too fine a game to stop even then.

Read article

Stay in the loop

Fresh reviews, hyped games and top lists — straight to your inbox, once a week.

BoardGame Verdict

© 2026 BoardGame Verdict

AboutMethodologyEthicsFAQContact UsPrivacy Policy·····
AD320×50